Elegant Designs

One of the most difficult things I find I have to do is coming up with an elegant solution for a difficult problem. Many problems can be solved in a rough and tumble sort of way by tackling it with brute force. However, when you really want an application that will scale well and perform at its peak you seek out those elegant solutions that look so obvious to someone who reads it, but are so difficult to come up with initially.

My basic theory when faced with coming up with a solution, or looking at improvements to a previous solution, is that if it looks more complicated than you think it should be, it probably is. But how do you reduce the complexity that seems so inherent in the problem at hand? There really isn’t a single answer to that question, else I would be selling it to the highest bidder and retiring by the time I was 30. However, there often exists a few good ways to shift your mind in a way that makes an elegant solution easier to emerge.

First, sometimes it is good to just step back for a moment. When you’re looking at the details of a problem intensely, you miss out on some of the larger picture things that can help you find a better solution. Recently I had a problem that I was pounding my head against for days. The problem was partially due to old requirements restricting my progress. I found that if you have the ability to look at some business requirements and discover that perhaps they aren’t really required, you can change the entire scope of your problem so that an elegant solution can emerge. Sometimes it is not possible to change a business requirement. Even when you can, changing the requirements can cause new difficulties to arise, such as migrating data. However, a confusing or complicated business rule should be changed if it makes it both difficult for you to design around and difficult for the users to understand.

Another method that I used on the same problem is exactly the opposite. Instead of looking back at a high level, dive down deeper. When looking at a problem and trying to come up with a solution you might have several ideas floating around in your head. You jot them down and think a little bit about how they might solve your problem, but you’re still unsure. If you have these possible solutions but are not sure if they would work, pick one and dive further into it. Try to draw it out more fully. Maybe create a prototype or fully design a database table or series of tables. Perhaps you can get a better idea of how something will interact by drawing up the interfaces between pieces of a program or writing out an algorithm is pseudocode. Instead of just viewing a problem from a high level, coming up with a solution, and immediately coding it, intermediate steps such as these can help you find flaws you wouldn’t encounter until implementation time when they’re more expensive to fix.

The best feeling in the world is taking an old design that took thousands of lines of code, or dozens of lines of generated and complicated SQL and reducing it to a few hundred lines of code and a line or two of SQL. Sometimes those types of changes can’t be made unless you change your schema or base objects, but if you’re able to change them to reduce complexity from something monolithic and unreadable to something small and concise, then you’ve discovered elegance.

Your work will be smoother, and your confidence higher if you find that elegant design.

Explore posts in the same categories: Design, Scalability

Tags: , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: